Skip to content

ETS-VII

The ETS-VII display model in the Space Dome at JAXA Tsukuba Space Center, showing the launch configuration in which the two spacecraft flew mated: the smaller target Orihime on top of the larger chaser Hikoboshi, which carries the deployable high-gain antenna. This is a museum display article, not flight hardware, and the manipulator is not represented on it Terrestrelasso, via Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 4.0.

Engineering Test Satellite VII was a Japanese two-spacecraft mission demonstrating autonomous rendezvous and docking and free-flying manipulation. It launched on 28 November 1997 [2]. The program is described in full by its project lead in [4]. The chaser, Hikoboshi, carried a 2 m six-degree-of-freedom manipulator; the smaller target, Orihime, was released and recaptured [2].

ParameterValueSource
Chaser mass2550 kg
Chaser inertia, Ixx / Iyy / Izz6200 / 3540 / 7090 kg m2
Target mass500 kg
Manipulator2 m, 6 DOF
Arm massabout 140 kg over six links[1], [5]
Arm attachment point in base frame(-0.79, -0.29, 1.00) m

Rows with no marker are from [1].

ParameterValueSource
Launch28 November 1997, H-II Launch Vehicle 6F from Tanegashima Space Center[2], [11]
International designationHikoboshi 1997-074B, Orihime 1997-074E[11]
Combined launch weight2,860 kg[11]
Orbitcircular, 550 km altitude, 35 degrees inclination, period about 96 minutes[1], [11]
Design life1.5 years[11]
Rendezvous-docking experiments conducted3[11]
Ground linkNASDA ground stations via the TDRS data relay satellite[11]
Planned end of the experiment programend of May 1999[1]
Extended toDecember 1999[1]

The arm masses about 140 kg across six links and carries a multisensory gripper and an advanced robotic hand supplied by MITI [1], [5]. Link parameters, which are what make the free-floating dynamics computable, are published in full [1]:

LinkLength (m)Mass (kg)Izz (kg m2)
10.35 (offset 0.28)35.01.69
20.8722.53.75
30.6321.92.53
4not stated16.50.072
5not stated26.00.13
6 (with end effector)0.5318.50.26

CCD cameras are carried at the shoulder and on the hand, and the hand carries force-torque sensing used for compliance and impedance control during contact tasks [6].

The arm masses about 140 kg on a 2550 kg base [1], so arm motion produces measurable base attitude change and the attitude controller’s response feeds back into the arm. The two systems are coupled through the base and neither can be designed in isolation.

The Generalized Jacobian Matrix maps joint rates to inertial-frame hand motion including that reaction, allowing resolved motion-rate control in inertial space on a free-floating base [1]. In flight, a 200 mm straight-line inertial path tracked at 10 mm/s held hand orientation at -22.8 degrees in the inertial frame while the base pitched 0.6 degrees under the reaction moment.

Reaction Null-Space control finds arm motions that produce zero net reaction on the base [5], and the same formulation applies to a manipulator on a flexible base, where the target is suppression of structural vibration rather than of rigid-body attitude change [9]. With a six degree-of-freedom non-redundant arm the null space available for this is n minus 3, so three of the six joint freedoms remain for reactionless motion [1]. Attitude variation during the final approach phase of a capture was held to 0.5 degrees peak to peak.

Gravity gradient torque is not negligible on this scale. In free drift the base attitude drifts more than one degree over several minutes [1], and beyond one degree of pointing error the high-bandwidth link is lost, which bounds how long the vehicle can be left in free-floating mode during an arm operation.

Round-trip delay from the NASDA ground station through TDRS was 6 to 7 seconds [3]. Motion commands were uploaded at 4 Hz in an isochronous synchronized stream [1].

Two compensation approaches were flown. The DLR GETEX experiment used task-directed programming with a predictive three-dimensional graphics display, an approach inherited from ROTEX, in which the operator commands a simulated arm on the ground and the flight arm follows [8]. The Kyoto and NASDA experiment instead closed a direct bilateral coupling with kinesthetic force feedback across the 6 to 7 second delay [3], which is the harder case because the delay sits inside the force loop rather than outside it. Under that scheme a slope-tracing task and an 18 mm peg-in-hole insertion with 0.4 mm clearance were performed without visual feedback, at a hand speed limited to 2.0 mm/s for safety.

Sensing is staged by range [2]:

PhaseSensorRange
Relative approachGPS relative navigation500 m and beyond
Final approachrendezvous laser radar500 m to 2 m
Dockingproximity sensor (PXS)2 m and closer

The vehicle holds at a 2 m virtual point for 15 minutes before the docking phase [2]. The handover between sensors, rather than any one sensor’s accuracy, is the design problem: each stage must acquire before the previous one loses the target, and the mission overview identifies autonomous rendezvous and docking as one of the two technology sets the mission existed to prove, alongside free-flying manipulation [4]. Docking approach velocity is 1 cm/s, contact acceleration peaks at 14 mm/s2, and the low impact specification is below 1.5 mg [2]. Achieved docking position accuracy under remote-piloted control was 1 cm.

Three flight programs were run. FP1 on 7 July 1998 separated at 1.8 cm/s and redocked successfully [2]. FP2 began on 7 August 1998, reached 12 km of separation, encountered a thruster pulse injection failure at intervals of one to a few seconds during final approach, and docked successfully after recovery on 27 August 1998. FP3 ran on 26 and 27 October 1999 and included an R-bar approach initiated 9 km from the target, with remote-piloted sequences flown from 2 m out to hold points at 6 m and 12 m [2].

Four experiment categories were flown: ground teleoperation under large time delay, orbital replacement unit exchange, space truss structure deployment and assembly, and antenna assembly [4]. Antenna reflector assembly was performed by teleoperation with vision and task-level sequencing [7]. The advanced robotic hand was evaluated separately against the ORU exchange and truss handling tasks, with compliance and impedance control closing on its force-torque sensor [6]. The GETEX sequence added a task-directed programming layer over the same hardware [8].

Capture of the free-flying target was performed with the hand starting about 400 mm from the grapple fixture against a target drifting at 10 mm/s, with the controller switching mode when hand position error fell below 100 mm [1].

Operations ran from the NASDA ground station through TDRS [3]. Three successive flight passes were used for the experiment set of 30 September 1999 [1], which is the shape of the constraint: work is bounded by pass length, not by arm speed. A summary of the mission’s dynamics results and their relation to the laboratory work that preceded them is given in [10].

References

  1. Yoshida, K. (2003). Engineering Test Satellite VII Flight Experiments for Space Robot Dynamics and Control: Theories on Laboratory Test Beds Ten Years Ago, Now in Orbit . The International Journal of Robotics Research, 5. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{yoshida2003engineering,
      title = {Engineering Test Satellite VII Flight Experiments for Space Robot Dynamics and Control: Theories on Laboratory Test Beds Ten Years Ago, Now in Orbit},
      author = {Yoshida, Kazuya},
      journal = {The International Journal of Robotics Research},
      volume = {22},
      number = {5},
      pages = {321--335},
      year = {2003},
      doi = {10.1177/0278364903022005003},
      abstract = {The Engineering Test Satellite VII (ETS-VII), an unmanned spacecraft equipped with a 2-m long, six-degree-of-freedom manipulator arm, was developed and launched by the National Space Development Agency of Japan (NASDA). ETS-VII has successfully carried out a variety of on-board experiments with its manipulator arm, and these key technologies are essential for an orbital free-flying robot. These results will provide a solid basis for future satellite servicing missions. This paper highlights manipulator control utilizing the concepts of the generalized Jacobian matrix and the reaction null-space. These concepts have been proposed and discussed for the past ten years using laboratory test beds, and their practical application has now been demonstrated in orbit.}
    }
  2. Kawano, I., Mokuno, M., Suzuki, T., Koyama, H. and Kunugi, M. (2002). Result of the ETS-VII Rendezvous Docking Experiment . Journal of the Japan Society for Aeronautical and Space Sciences, 578. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{kawano2002result,
      title = {Result of the ETS-VII Rendezvous Docking Experiment},
      author = {Kawano, Isao and Mokuno, Masaaki and Suzuki, Takashi and Koyama, Hiroshi and Kunugi, Masaaki},
      journal = {Journal of the Japan Society for Aeronautical and Space Sciences},
      volume = {50},
      number = {578},
      pages = {95--102},
      year = {2002},
      doi = {10.2322/jjsass.50.95},
      abstract = {ETS–VII is a test satellite to perform in-orbit demonstration of autonomous rendezvous docking (RVD) technology, which will be necessary for advanced space activities in the early 21st century. ETS–VII performed three RVD experiment flights, and verified all technical items. ETS–VII demonstrated first autonomous RVD between unmanned vehicles, and remote piloted rendezvous flight position accuracy at docking was about 1cm, and acceleration was less than 1.5mG (low impact docking). In the second RVD experiment flight, ETS–VII detected attitude anomaly and executed disable abort for safety insurance. We present the results and evaluation of three RVD experiment flights in this paper.}
    }
  3. Imaida, T., Yokokohji, Y., Doi, T., Oda, M. and Yoshikawa, T. (2003). Ground-Space Teleoperation of a Robot Arm Mounted on Engineering Test Satellite No. VII by Direct Bilateral Coupling under a Long Time Delay Condition . Journal of the Robotics Society of Japan, 3. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{imaida2003groundb,
      title = {Ground-Space Teleoperation of a Robot Arm Mounted on Engineering Test Satellite No. VII by Direct Bilateral Coupling under a Long Time Delay Condition},
      author = {Imaida, Takashi and Yokokohji, Yasuyoshi and Doi, Toshitsugu and Oda, Mitsushige and Yoshikawa, Tsuneo},
      journal = {Journal of the Robotics Society of Japan},
      volume = {21},
      number = {3},
      pages = {309--320},
      year = {2003},
      doi = {10.7210/jrsj.21.309},
      abstract = {A bilateral teleoperation experiment with Engineering Test Satellite No.VII (ETS-VII) was conducted on November 22, 1999. Round-trip time for communication between the NASDA ground station and ETS-VII was approximately six to seven seconds. We constructed a bilateral teleoperator that is stable even under such a long time delay. Several experiments, such as slope tracing task and peg-in-hole task, were carried out. Task performance was compared between bilateral mode and unilateral mode with force telemetry data visually displayed on a screen. All tasks were possible by bilateral control without any visual information. Experimental results showed that kinesthetic force feedback to the operator is helpful even under such long time delay and improves the performance of the task.}
    }
  4. Oda, M. (1999). Mission of ETS-VII . Journal of the Robotics Society of Japan, 8. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{oda1999space,
      title = {Mission of ETS-VII},
      author = {Oda, Mitsushige},
      journal = {Journal of the Robotics Society of Japan},
      volume = {17},
      number = {8},
      pages = {1055--1061},
      year = {1999},
      doi = {10.7210/jrsj.17.1055}
    }
  5. Yoshida, K., Hashizume, K. and Abiko, S. (2001). Zero Reaction Maneuver: Flight Validation with ETS-VII Space Robot and Extension to Kinematically Redundant Arm . IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Source
    BibTeX
    @inproceedings{yoshida2001zero,
      title = {Zero Reaction Maneuver: Flight Validation with ETS-VII Space Robot and Extension to Kinematically Redundant Arm},
      author = {Yoshida, Kazuya and Hashizume, Kenichi and Abiko, Satoko},
      booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
      volume = {1},
      pages = {441--446},
      year = {2001},
      doi = {10.1109/robot.2001.932590},
      abstract = {Presents the experimental results and post-flight analysis of reaction null-space based reactionless manipulation, or zero reaction maneuver (ZRM). The concept has been developed with an insight into the motion dynamics of free-flying multibody systems and its practical availability is clearly demonstrated with ETS-VII, a Japanese space robot. The ZRM is proven particularly useful for removing the velocity limit of manipulation due to the reaction constraint and the time loss due to waiting for the attitude recovery. The existence of the ZRM is very limited for a 6 DOF manipulator arm mounted on a free-flying base, but it is discussed how more operational freedom is obtained with a kinematically redundant arm.}
    }
  6. Machida, K., Akita, K., Ohno, K., Moriya, M., Nishida, H. and Ohsawa, T. (1999). Space Experiment Evaluation of Advanced Robotic Hand System Boarded on ETS-VII . Journal of Space Technology and Science, 2. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{machida1999space,
      title = {Space Experiment Evaluation of Advanced Robotic Hand System Boarded on ETS-VII},
      author = {Machida, Kazuo and Akita, K. and Ohno, K. and Moriya, M. and Nishida, H. and Ohsawa, T.},
      journal = {Journal of Space Technology and Science},
      volume = {14},
      number = {2},
      pages = {21--30},
      year = {1999},
      doi = {10.11230/jsts.14.2_21}
    }
  7. Kimura, S., Tsuchiya, S., Nagai, Y. and Morikawa, H. (1999). Antenna-Assembly Experiments Using ETS-VII . Journal of Space Technology and Science, 2. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{kimura1999antenna,
      title = {Antenna-Assembly Experiments Using ETS-VII},
      author = {Kimura, Shinichi and Tsuchiya, S. and Nagai, Y. and Morikawa, H.},
      journal = {Journal of Space Technology and Science},
      volume = {14},
      number = {2},
      pages = {15--20},
      year = {1999},
      doi = {10.11230/jsts.14.2_15}
    }
  8. Landzettel, K., Brunner, B., Schreiber, G., Steinmetz, B.-M. and Hirzinger, G. (1999). The NASDA-DLR Joint Robotics Experiment GETEX . Journal of the Robotics Society of Japan, 8. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{landzettel1999nasdab,
      title = {The NASDA-DLR Joint Robotics Experiment GETEX},
      author = {Landzettel, Klaus and Brunner, Bernhard and Schreiber, Gerhard and Steinmetz, Bernhard-Michael and Hirzinger, Gerd},
      journal = {Journal of the Robotics Society of Japan},
      booktitle = {International Symposium on Artificial Intelligence, Robotics and Automation in Space (i-SAIRAS)},
      volume = {17},
      number = {8},
      pages = {1086--1095},
      year = {1999},
      doi = {10.7210/jrsj.17.1086},
      abstract = {This paper describes the GETEX (German ETS-VII EXperiments) joint robotics experiments, which has been conducted in April '99 at the first free-floating space robot on NASDA's ETS-VII satellite [1] . All the experiments have been performed and controlled from DLR's ground control system for space robotics applications which was connected to NASDA's ground station in Tsukuba. The telerobotic system combines sensor-based task-level teleprogramrning (as the basis for autonomy) with the features of teleoperation and shared autonomy. The hierarchical system structure is shown as well as the flexibility in programming and controlling each kind of space robotics application. This approach has led to a modular task-directed programming scheme, called Modular A & R Controller (MARCO), which provides a very flexible architecture to adapt the application-specific requirements to a given controlling scheme. A peg-in-hole experiment, using VR methods and the “vision & force” control scheme, by closing sensor control loops directly on-board (force) and via the ground control system (vision) is explained. During GETEX we conducted experiments with relevance to the behavior of ETS-VII in free motion mode in order to verify the existing dynamic models.}
    }
  9. Nenchev, D. N., Yoshida, K., Vichitkulsawat, P. and Uchiyama, M. (1999). Reaction Null-Space Control of Flexible Structure Mounted Manipulator Systems . IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation, 6. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{nenchev1999reaction,
      title = {Reaction Null-Space Control of Flexible Structure Mounted Manipulator Systems},
      author = {Nenchev, Dragomir N. and Yoshida, Kazuya and Vichitkulsawat, P. and Uchiyama, Masaru},
      journal = {IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation},
      volume = {15},
      number = {6},
      pages = {1011--1023},
      year = {1999},
      doi = {10.1109/70.817666},
      abstract = {A composite control law for end-effector path tracking with a flexible structure mounted manipulator system is proposed, such that no disturbances on the flexible base are induced. The control law is based on the reaction null-space concept introduced earlier to tackle dynamic interaction problems of free-floating robots, or moving base robots in general. The control law is called composite since it ensures base vibration suppression control as well, although independently of the reactionless motion control subtask. The requirement of task independence is essential to avoid the appearance of complex dynamics expressions in the control law, such as nonlinear velocity-dependent coupling terms and dependencies of inertias on the elastic coordinates. We present experimental data from computer simulations and the experimental test bed TREP developed at Tohoku university. The experimental data is shown to agree well with theory.}
    }
  10. Yoshida, K. (2001). Space Robot Dynamics and Control: To Orbit, From Orbit, and Future . Robotics Research. Source
    BibTeX
    @article{yoshida2001space,
      title = {Space Robot Dynamics and Control: To Orbit, From Orbit, and Future},
      author = {Yoshida, Kazuya},
      journal = {Robotics Research},
      pages = {449-456},
      year = {2001},
      doi = {10.1007/978-1-4471-0765-1_54}
    }
  11. Kwon, D., Hwang, D.-H., Babcock, S. and Burks, B. (1994). Input Shaping Filter Methods for the Control of Structurally Flexible, Long-Reach Manipulators . IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation. Source
    BibTeX
    @inproceedings{kwon1994input,
      title = {Input Shaping Filter Methods for the Control of Structurally Flexible, Long-Reach Manipulators},
      author = {Kwon, Dong‐Soo and Hwang, Dong-Hwan and Babcock, S.M. and Burks, B.L.},
      booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
      volume = {1},
      pages = {3259-3264},
      year = {1994},
      doi = {10.1109/robot.1994.351069},
      abstract = {Within the Environmental Restoration and Waste Management Program of the US Department of Energy, the remediation of single-shell radioactive waste storage tanks is one of the areas that challenges state-of-the-art equipment and methods. Concepts that utilize long-reach manipulators are being seriously considered for this task. Due to high payload capacity and high length-to-cross-section ratio requirements, these long-reach manipulator systems are expected to exhibit significant structural flexibility. To avoid structural vibrations during operation, various types of shaping filter methods have been investigated. A robust notch filtering method and an impulse shaping method were used as simulation benchmarks. In addition to that, two very different approaches have been developed and compared. One new approach, referred to as a "feedforward simulation filter", uses imbedded simulation with complete knowledge of the system dynamics. The other approach, "fuzzy shaping method", employs a fuzzy logic method to modify the joint trajectory from the desired end-position trajectory without precise knowledge of the system dynamics.>}
    }

Further reading

  • Nenchev, D. N., Umetani, Y. and Yoshida, K. (1992). Analysis of a redundant free-flying spacecraft/manipulator system . IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation. Source
  • Nenchev, D. N., Yoshida, K. and Uchiyama, M. (1996). Reaction Null-Space Based Control of Flexible Structure Mounted Manipulator Systems . IEEE Conference on Decision and Control. Source
  • Yoshida, K., Nenchev, D. N., Hashizume, K., Abiko, S. and Oda, M. (2002). Flight Experiments of ETS-VII for Advanced Space Robot Control . Journal of the Japan Society for Aeronautical and Space Sciences. Source
  • (2026). JAXA: ETS-VII. global.jaxa.jp/projects/sat/ets7